Although it failed to repeat the debut album’s phenomenal commercial success, second album Comedy better meets the promise of Black’s early singles, comprising mainly wry ballads and broadening Black’s appeal. The songwriting is less guarded and more daring here: ‘Let me watch you make love’ is Black’s most intimate recording, and dedicating ‘All we need is the money’ to the people of Liverpool represents Colin’s most overtly political statement on record. Colin described the album as ‘lighter and more lyrical’ than ‘Wonderful life’.
Time Out’s Laura Lee Davies wrote: “Immaculate songs like ‘The Big One’, ‘You’re a big girl now’ and ‘All we need is the money’… melt irresistibly over your heart with the epic charms of a kitsch French movie. There’s no flag waving or duelling guitars here, just the odd blustery crescendo and some Spanish flavouring… Smooth, very smooth.”
Comedy was issued in the US with different tracks, including remixes of ‘Wonderful life’ and ‘Sweetest Smile’. Robin Millar, best known for his work with Sade, shared production duties with Dave Dix.
Do you remember the way things used to be? Our lives untainted by memory And we laughed, and we cried, and we played, and we fought And never stopped to think Oh never stopped to think
That this could be (This could be the Big One) Explain just how we came to part I never really wanted to
And now we flounder in the wake of those days we wish we’d never found out each other’s ways And we laugh, and we flirt and we cry, and make love Could it be the same? How could it be the same?
Oh tell me how we came to part I never really wanted to
I can laugh about it now, but couldn’t then You made me ache, so I went for a run In the driving rain Through your neighbourhood streets And there you were, a silhouette in the wet night air Me in my pumps in the pouring rain A kind of despair upon finding you there Couldn’t whisper your name
Oh, I can laugh about it now by your side Oh, I can laugh about it now by your side Oh, sha la la la, we’re all in trouble Is there room in the sky for all of us angels here?
And the very next day, through the shrieks of the crowd Came your careless self, your oh-so-couldn’t careless self And you just pass me by, your friends catch my eyes “We know you love her, we saw you dancing with her shadow” And I couldn’t disagree, and for the life of me I could call out your name, and call out your name, And call out your name
Oh, I can laugh about it now by your side Oh, I can laugh about it now by your side Oh, sha la la la, we’re all in trouble Is there room in the sky for all of us angels here?
Sha la la la, oh, we’re all in trouble, Or is there room in the sky for all of us angels here?
I can laugh about it now I can laugh about it now by your side
Oh, sha la la la, we’re all in trouble Or is there room in the sky for all of us angels here?
I never courted suffering, never valued paid I’m not cruel, or a fool, just not used to it And now our fingers stay where once they hurried past We’ve the time and the place, let’s get used to it
And never feel lonely (I don’t want to) And never stay hungry (I don’t care to) You are what people say you are Whatever people say you are How can you stay happy?
We never would admit, no not to a man If you can’t get what you want, get what you can But you always made me feel like I’ve just received an invite to last week’s Halloween
I’ll never feel lonely (I don’t want to) I’ll never stay hungry (I don’t care to) You are what people say you are Whatever people say you are How can you stay happy?
If I’m wrong I will take it all back If you ask It’s the price of good fortune I ask If I can, if I can
You’re a big girl now With a big girl’s needs And a big girl’s dreams and promises Why don’t you accept yourself? Accept your desires Meet your needs Deny your problems
And don’t cry, cry, don’t cry you’re a big girl now
It’s so hard to be humble When you know you’re worth more To live and learn Is all we can hope for An attraction of pasts Like the blindness of the summer sun But what will you do On when the rain comes through?
And don’t cry, cry, don’t cry you’re a big girl now
Sometimes I wonder at this shame I hide Pare away the man and find the worm inside Your mind’s unclear and instinct is a lie I hear what you say you’d do And I wish it were true
How can he take you when you give yourself? All the old lies just to bind yourself Then you wrap yourself around me and Whisper in my ear ‘where is your jealousy?’ all I feel is fear I want to hear you, I want to see Let me watch you make love And imagine that it’s me
Hey, hey what you say just might be true But I still can’t take a chance on you if it’s true Oh if it’s true We’ve had our problems just trying to make the whole thing last You thought that we might break if we drove too fast Oh it is true Just like I used to do
I was right, you were wrong Who’s picking holes in who? You were always a silly child I was right, you were wrong Oh look at you You were always a silly child
Hey, hey what you say just might be true Then there’ll be nothing left of me and you when I’m through if it’s true You are my target, I plan to make this last a while I could sit and watch you suffer with a smile Just like I used to do
I was right, you were wrong Who’s picking holes in who? You were always a silly child I was right, you were wrong Oh look at you You were always a silly child
I make no promises I make no guarantees It makes no difference When you’re all at sea
Try me for money You can try me for days I’ll be indifferent When you’ve none you can’t pay
Say something good to me Say it’s not always You’ve got the power Now give us the means We can do it, we can do it All we need is the money
You made your preference You made your guarantee And it made no difference We’re still all at sea
Tell me it’s working now You can tell me for day I’ll be indifferent There’s no justice this way
Say something good to me Say it’s not always You’ve got the power Now give us the means We can do it, we can do it All we need is the money You’ve got the power Now give us the means
Well now, you wouldn’t stay And there’s not much more that I can say But your lips that I kissed Will never go away From my memory They will remain with me
You were tied, now you’re gone There was time, now it’s gone
Is this the best we can do? Have we come as far as we intend to? This was comedy, it is true I was not innocent under you
Ah, my memories they will remain with me
You were tied, now you’re gone There was time, now it’s gone
It’s late and I’m drunk and my stomach Sounds like the hot water pipes in the attic room And who’d have thought the sky could hold so much snow inside of it just to let it go
So? The stars may shine and the moon may be blue But what comes, comes from you?
So don’t turn around cause that’s paradise lost Don’t turn away Mersey rose Nothing good could last forever So don’t turn around that’s paradise lost The very place that we chose Only dreams could last forever
I was meant to take you there We could pack our bags and be on our way Hold on to your childlike fears All your worries, tantrums, tears I don’t need to know
So? The stars may shine and the moon may be blue But what comes, comes from you?
So don’t turn around cause that’s paradise lost Don’t turn away Mersey rose Nothing good could last forever So don’t turn around that’s paradise lost The very place that we chose Only dreams could last forever
Hold it now, there is something you should know I would never turn away from you My intentions are clear That’s the only truth My only wish is never to lose
So don’t turn around cause that’s paradise lost Don’t turn away Mersey rose Nothing good could last forever So don’t turn around that’s paradise lost The very place that we chose Only dreams could last forever
13 comments on “Comedy”
This album is in my top 50 list of all time. You can listen it over and over. I think it is clearly one of the most underrated albums of all time as well.
Highly recommended
Listened this album for thousand times maybe, and will go on for million times……
If I should have to live with only 3 albums, this one would definitly be part of it! Already listened a hundred times and still glad to listen again… Music sometimes bluesy and sad and sometimes joyful and happy is just perfect. Black voice is just a pure wonder and surprising when reaching higher notes. Beautiful melodies you want to hear again and again Each song has its own mood and are well chosen to complete the tracklist.
Thank you so much Colin to share your feelings and talent with us.
PS : Please think about France for a live tour!
I grew up listening to this CD from my father’s collection and years on still love the music.
I wish you would make it down to South Africa one of these days! Regards
I’ve recently revisited this album after a gap of about 20 years and it’s a truly outstanding recording.
Unfortunately, there is one track that I dislike intensely – It’s Not Over Yet – but the remaining tracks are sublime. You’re a Big Girl Now and I Can Laugh About it Now are perfection, while No-one None Nothing and All We Need Is the Money are only a shade behind. Along with another couple of tracks from his early albums – Sweetest Smile and Feel Like Change – I believe these songs are as good as any recorded by anyone from 1987-1991. The combination of strong lyrical songwriting and arrangement with Colin’s warm, soulful and wistful voice is timeless.
i have been looking for this album in iTunes and I can’t find it. Somebody please help
This album has played such a huge part in my life. Its a classic. Please get well soon Colin…
I’ve been listening to Comedy a lot since I heard the sad news of Colin’s passing. His voice is utterly transporting on this fabulous, moving record that anyone’s life would be improved by owning. Thanks and goodbye Colin. I’ll miss your songs and voice.
Words fail me! i just discovered that Colin has passed. His voice will live on and is a huge part of the soundtrack of my life. Thanks for all the years of really rich, beautiful music will will never stop being played in my head.
This album is a work of genius. Every track flows and works. Such and underrated piece of Work and I’ve lost my copy Any suggestions greatly appreciate
when i was younger ,i fall in love with this songs,i never forget u Black…
One of my all time albums. Mediterranean sounding. Folkish. A bit of Cohen. Nothing can touch this. Not even in 2021. RIP Colin. Miss your melancholic voice.
I just listened to Comedy , when it came out i was 20 years old ,military service and first love …. this album always touches me enormously with these lyrical flights full of violins and love and heart , thank you ,colin , Patrick
13 comments on “Comedy”
This album is in my top 50 list of all time. You can listen it over and over. I think it is clearly one of the most underrated albums of all time as well.
Highly recommended
Listened this album for thousand times maybe, and will go on for million times……
If I should have to live with only 3 albums, this one would definitly be part of it!
Already listened a hundred times and still glad to listen again…
Music sometimes bluesy and sad and sometimes joyful and happy is just perfect.
Black voice is just a pure wonder and surprising when reaching higher notes.
Beautiful melodies you want to hear again and again
Each song has its own mood and are well chosen to complete the tracklist.
Thank you so much Colin to share your feelings and talent with us.
PS : Please think about France for a live tour!
I grew up listening to this CD from my father’s collection and years on still love the music.
I wish you would make it down to South Africa one of these days!
Regards
I’ve recently revisited this album after a gap of about 20 years and it’s a truly outstanding recording.
Unfortunately, there is one track that I dislike intensely – It’s Not Over Yet – but the remaining tracks are sublime. You’re a Big Girl Now and I Can Laugh About it Now are perfection, while No-one None Nothing and All We Need Is the Money are only a shade behind. Along with another couple of tracks from his early albums – Sweetest Smile and Feel Like Change – I believe these songs are as good as any recorded by anyone from 1987-1991. The combination of strong lyrical songwriting and arrangement with Colin’s warm, soulful and wistful voice is timeless.
i have been looking for this album in iTunes and I can’t find it. Somebody please help
This album has played such a huge part in my life. Its a classic. Please get well soon Colin…
I’ve been listening to Comedy a lot since I heard the sad news of Colin’s passing. His voice is utterly transporting on this fabulous, moving record that anyone’s life would be improved by owning. Thanks and goodbye Colin. I’ll miss your songs and voice.
Words fail me! i just discovered that Colin has passed. His voice will live on and is a huge part of the soundtrack of my life. Thanks for all the years of really rich, beautiful music will will never stop being played in my head.
This album is a work of genius. Every track flows and works. Such and underrated piece of Work and I’ve lost my copy Any suggestions greatly appreciate
when i was younger ,i fall in love with this songs,i never forget u Black…
One of my all time albums. Mediterranean sounding. Folkish. A bit of Cohen. Nothing can touch this. Not even in 2021. RIP Colin. Miss your melancholic voice.
I just listened to Comedy , when it came out i was 20 years old ,military service and first love …. this album always touches me enormously with these lyrical flights full of violins and love and heart , thank you ,colin , Patrick